Rationality Now Rotating Header Image

It seems I was a bit vague.

My last post about gluten-free communion wafers seems to have a conclusion that is a bit vague… at least a lot more vague than I’d intended (ie… not at all). The two commenters, “David” and “stephanie” concluded that my post was criticizing the Catholic church’s position on the gluten content of the Eucharist hosts.

The Catholic church doctrine seems to require that hosts contain gluten in order to qualify as “bread,” otherwise it cannot properly transubstantiate into the body of Christ. This, of course, poses a problem for coeliac sufferers who cannot tolerate any gluten in their diets.

Although I agree one hundred percent with the comments made by “David” and “stephanie,” and I support them in their fight to be included in their religious ceremonies, the issue of immutable church doctrine was not the focused intent of my post.

My intended point was that, since the Catholic church believes that the host physically transforms into the body of Christ, the wafer would no longer contain gluten when it’s eaten. So, if what Catholics profess to believe is actually true, the host could be made of 100% wheat gluten before being consecrated, but afterward it would contain 0% gluten and would be safe to eat, even by the most severe coeliac sufferer.

Since it’s obviously an issue (and a completely valid one, I agree), it would seem that Catholics, including the clergy, do not really believe that transubstantiation occurs. And more importantly, if any coeliac sufferer has ever had a reaction to a consecrated host (a brief search turned up nothing), it would seem that transubstantiation actually does not occur.

My sincerest best wishes to “David” and “stephanie,” though.

One Comment

  1. Hey, can we start a debate on if Superman would beat-up on Batman?

    And whilst we are in the realms of fantasy why just, confine ourselves to Marvel Heroes, and include Dracula as well?

    You are entirely correct in belittling the ridiculous 1950’s b-grade science fiction concept called ‘transformation’ (remember the film ‘The Fly’?)

    Is this like the secret-recipe to KFC or Coke and the ingredients are held in The Vatican vault?

    Utterly ludicrous, proposition on any scale and there’s no need to apologise to anyone who has got up-set, when you called their favourite comic book hero ‘a wimp’

    Great blog topic.

    Paul

Leave a Reply to Paul from Canterbury Atheists Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.